{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"NewsArticle","generatedAt":"2026-07-23T08:01:28.298Z","headline":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员因公司签署无限制军事AI协议而离职","description":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner因谷歌向国土安全部出售云服务并最终签署无限制军事AI协议而离职。他曾起草25页提案要求加入禁止杀手机器人和大规模监控的合同条款，但提案被CEO转交后无人跟进。Turner指出，包括Jeff Dean和Stuart Russell在内的多位AI伦理领袖在关键时刻未能兑现承诺。","url":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","mainEntityOfPage":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","datePublished":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","dateModified":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","inLanguage":"zh-CN","publisher":{"@type":"NewsMediaOrganization","name":"Aioga","url":"https://www.aioga.com"},"citation":["https://turntrout.com/why-i-left-google-deepmind","https://aihot.virxact.com/items/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo"],"canonicalUrl":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","directAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner自述，因不认同谷歌向美国国土安全部相关机构提供云服务，并认为公司签署的军事AI协议缺少对杀手机器人和大规模监控用途的限制，最终选择离职。","url":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","dateCreated":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","author":{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https://www.aioga.com/authors/aioga-editorial/#editorial-team","name":"Aioga Editorial Team","url":"https://www.aioga.com/authors/aioga-editorial/"}},"evidence":[{"@type":"CreativeWork","name":"turntrout.com source article","url":"https://turntrout.com/why-i-left-google-deepmind","datePublished":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","provider":{"@type":"Organization","name":"turntrout.com","url":"https://turntrout.com/why-i-left-google-deepmind"}},{"@type":"CreativeWork","name":"AIHot archive record","url":"https://aihot.virxact.com/items/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo","datePublished":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","provider":{"@type":"Organization","name":"AIHot","url":"https://aihot.virxact.com/items/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo"}}],"aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","originalPublisher":{"name":"turntrout.com","url":"https://turntrout.com/why-i-left-google-deepmind"},"article":{"id":"cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo","slug":"cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo","url":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","title":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员因公司签署无限制军事AI协议而离职","title_en":"我为何离开谷歌DeepMind","summary":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner因谷歌向国土安全部出售云服务并最终签署无限制军事AI协议而离职。他曾起草25页提案要求加入禁止杀手机器人和大规模监控的合同条款，但提案被CEO转交后无人跟进。Turner指出，包括Jeff Dean和Stuart Russell在内的多位AI伦理领袖在关键时刻未能兑现承诺。","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","sourceUrl":"https://turntrout.com/why-i-left-google-deepmind","aiHotUrl":"https://aihot.virxact.com/items/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo","publishedAt":"2026-07-15T19:37:38.646Z","category":"技巧观点","score":73,"selected":true,"articleBody":["In January, Department of Homeland Security ( dhs ) officers killed at l east ：https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/28/deaths-ice-2026- two people. In both cases, a federal agent grasped his gun, aimed it at a peaceful citizen, and shot them dead.","I learned that Google sells its Cloud services to the relevant agencies within dhs . ：#google-supports-the-immigration-enforcement-supply-chain I thought that was wrong. Federal agents should not be able to kill citizens in the street. I set out to find the most effective way to push my company to stop serving these agencies. My divestment campaign quickly broadened into an attempt to prevent Google from signing an unethical military AI deal, as the Pentagon started pressuring AI providers into military AI deals with no restrictions against use for killer robots or mass surveillance. 1：#user-content-fn-surveil","I wanted AI ethics commitments to hold under pressure. In particular, I wanted Google DeepMind ( gdm ) to maintain its existing commitment against supporting killer rob ots. ：#preparing-for-lunch-with-jeff-dean Over several months, I asked many people to act. I asked senior people⁠—respected people⁠—people with reputations silvered by their concern about AI ethics and safety. Nearly all declined.","Take Stuart Russell, a famous AI researcher who spent over a decade crusading against autonomous weapons. I worked at his lab for years. At a conference, on-stage, he agreed to push his organization to make a statement supporting AI providers against government coercion and promised a poll of the organization’s members. The statement and poll both vanished.","Or take Jeff Dean, who is Google’s Chief Scientist and the co-lead of Google’s Gemini AI project. In 2018, Jeff signed a pledge to never support the development or use of killer robots. I got Jeff to publicly and boldly co-sign an amicus brief (where outsiders weigh in to sway a lawsuit) backing Anthropic against the Pentagon. But I also asked him to use his immense leverage to stop Google from making its own unethical deal with the military, and I don’t think he did. He remains at Google despite his pledge.","I wrote a 25-⁠page proposal containing contract language and oversight mechanisms. Military- and surveillance-law experts praised the proposal, which represented a principled counteroffer Google could have stood by. I sent the proposal to Demis Hassabis ( gdm ’s ceo ) who routed it to senior policy staff, only for the proposal to wilt unattended until Google signed a deal.","Senior management had insisted that Google wouldn’t sign. I disagreed with them, but they largely ignored my warnings. While I may have increased the Pentagon’s hesitation around the d eal, ：#jeff-signs-an-amicus-brief-supporting-anthropic Google still signed a deal handing over their AI without restrictions against killer robots or mass AI spying. Google’s contract restrictions were even weaker than OpenAI’s.：https://fortune.com/2026/05/04/google-employee-backlash-pentagon-ai-contract-power-waned-since-project-maven/ At that point, I couldn’t stay at Google in good conscience, so I left.","This essay tells the story of why I left Google DeepMind. It is also the story of something larger: how powerful people and institutions failed, one after another, to keep their AI ethics promises in the face of pressure.","Throughout this essay, I never quote anyone’s private words without permission. Where private conversations matter, I characterize them minimally. I otherwise keep to my own actions, public information, and official communications. You can’t verify my characterizations, so weight them accordingly. This minimization has cut content which would have supported my arguments.","After Alex Pretti’s death, I was determined to take effective act ion. ：https://turntrout.substack.com/p/a-winter-spent-by-the-pond To determine how to reduce harm from dhs , I researched Big Tech’s entanglement. Certainly, Microsoft and Amazon have larger involvement,：https://www.forbes.com/sites/the-wiretap/2026/01/27/immigration-record-spend-on-amazon-and-trump/ but I was surprised to learn of Google’s exposure.","The stereotypical activist action is to make a petition. But Google had already ignored a large petition on this is sue. ：https://www.cnbc.com/2026/02/07/nearly-a-thousand-google-workers-sign-letter-urging-company-to-divest-from-ice-cbp.html Plus, Google’s executives likely hardened their company against stereotypical organizing tactics. Sit-ins, strikes, even a mass of Google engineers quitting: I deemed all of them ineffective (if I could even pull them off).","As I strategized, I judged that Google would not care about 100 random research engineers quitting. No, in the AI industry, talent is top-heavy and teams are driven by a few hard-to-replace stars. I didn’t need to coordinate 100 engineers. Perhaps I just needed to coordinate 10.","I’d followed the news and guessed that Sundar Pichai (Google’s ceo ) was more of a businessman than a “make me a big speech about ethics and I’ll change my mind” kind of guy. But if a few hard-to-replace people were ready to walk, that would matter for the business, so Sundar might listen.","That’s when I remembered reading Jeff Dean tweeting about how bad ice was, retweeting Anne Frank quotes. Maybe I didn’t even need 10 engineers, I just needed one .","Jeff is considered a saint at Google. He was Google’s 30 th employee, developed key algorithms, and is known as a man of principle. A common joke: it’s easier for Jeff Dean’s resume to list what he hasn’t achieved than what he has. He’s Google’s Chief Scientist and a co-lead of Google’s Gemini effort. A Jeff departure would be a disaster for the company.","But if Jeff cared so much and had so much leverage, why was Google in these ice contracts in the first place? Of course, you can’t be Chief Scientist and constantly get what you want by threatening to quit. But I still felt confused.","At first I thought about who could put me in touch with him. But (and this is a good general lesson) if you want to talk to someone about something, you can always just ask them !","I told Jeff that I respected him for speaking out, that I wanted Google to divest from the dhs supply chain. I asked if he shared these goals and, if so, how I could help.","He suggested it’d be reasonable for me to email a few guys. Their names: Sundar Pichai ( ceo of Google), Demis Hassabis ( ceo of Google DeepMind), and Thomas Kurian ( ceo of Google Cloud). I thought “sure, Jeff. No problem. I’ll just tell them what I think.”","I’m writing as a concerned employee at gdm . I recently messaged Jeff Dean regarding my concerns. He suggested that directly emailing the three of you was a reasonable next step.","I have no problem with Google working with lawful administrations of either US political party. My concern is not about politics, but rather about the events enabled by Google’s role in the dhs supply chain.","I think that ice has gone well beyond its legal mandate to remove illegal immigrants from the country in an orderly fashion. According to watchdogs, ice operations frequently deprive targets of due process. These operations regularly detain citi zens ：https://www.cbsnews.com/minnesota/news/woman-american-citizen-describes-being-held-by-ice-for-two-days/ in facilities operating with minimal (or no) legal oversight.：https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/press-release/report-trump-immigration-detention-2026/ Over 1,000 people are missing from one such location.：https://www.projectcensored.org/detainees-missing-ice-alligator-alcatraz/ At other locations, the aclu reports human rights abuses and a severe lack of safety for detainees.：https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/detained-immigrants-detail-physical-abuse-and-inhumane-conditions-at-largest-immigration-detention-center-in-the-u-s","These are not standard, legitimate enforcement activities. These operations are troubling from a human rights perspective and also pose reputational risk to any vendors involved.","On 1/28/26, the dhs posted its 2025 AI Use Case Inventory,：https://www.dhs.gov/publication/ai-use-case-inventory-library which lists Google as one of several GenAI providers which “improve the operational efficiency” of dhs . I urge Google to immediately stop working with ice (and dhs more broadly), including via support for third-party integrators facilitating these specific operations. Whether through a direct (“prime”) contract or through intermediaries (like ITC Federal：https://itcfederal.com/news/itc-federal-achieves-ato-for-dhs-ice-cloud/), Cloud and Gemini must not power these operations.","History will judge the tech sector by its involvement in these events. I love working at Google, and I want to ensure Google is on the right side of that history.","They never replied. I returned to Jeff and asked for a lunch to discuss constructive opportunities for real change within Google. I told him: “any time, any place. I’ll drive down to Mountain View to meet with you.”","At this point, I thought this was where “plan A” would fail. To my surprise, he actually accepted, for a lunch a few weeks out.","The Pentagon wanted the frontier AI lab Anthropic to remove red lines from its existing contract: red lines against lethal autonomous weapons systems and AI spying / profiling. The ultimatum was essentially “give us your product or we will designate you a supply chain ri sk.” ：https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/24/us/politics/pentagon-anthropic.html The government wanted the AI for “all lawful use.”","There were two major problems with that kind of deal.","I’d been following the Anthropic⁠–Pentagon standoff for weeks. That morning, I read about the ultimatum. I was attending a conference in Paris held by the International Association for Safe and Ethical AI ( iaseai ), which is a nonprofit：https://iaseai.org/about founded in 2024 to be “a unified voice” for safe and ethical AI. The world-famous AI scientist Stuart Russell chairs its steering committee. Its 2026 working groups：https://iaseai.org/working-groups include “Red Lines for Advanced AI,” focused on “autonomous weapons and escalation.” iaseai seemed built for a moment like this.","Iaseai ’s venue would be full of influential AI professionals who care about ethics. I thought: we can organize a response, as a field, in support of 1) Anthropic’s right to do business without threat of destruction and 2) actual standards for whether and how to integrate AI into lethal autonomous weapons systems and surveillance apparatuses.","Anthropic had two days to comply with the administration’s demands. Perhaps other companies would agree to these “all lawful use” terms before the deadline. The main question which weighed on me: can I stop Google from caving, from accepting an “all lawful use” deal? If Anthropic says “no” and Google also says “no,” now we’re getting somewhere. That seemed hard. I wanted to make it happen anyway. Google could cave at any moment, whether before the Friday deadline or after.","When I arrived at the iaseai venue, I expected some of the hundreds of AI professionals to be discussing the urgent ai ethics news which just dropped. Instead, no one besides me brought it up. People busied themselves with the usual abstractions: “how does public choice theory inform coordination problems?”.","Most importantly: the leading figure in the global campaign to ban lethal autonomous weapons,：https://awards.acm.org/award_winners/russell_3816360 with his site highlighting over two hundred prestigious talks on the subject .：https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~russell/research/LAWS.html He presented the Slaughter bots ：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-2tpwW0kmU vi deos ：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rDo1QxI260 to the United Nations. If anyone on this green planet Earth had a reason to call out an “all lawful use” military AI deal, it was the man who organized the field against slaughterbots .","I briskly gathered information. Hinton was speaking remotely, so I’d have to reach him indirectly, likely through Bengio or Stuart. I knew Stuart already and had a friend who could get me in touch. Bengio was the wildcard. I saw him leaving the venue, so I ran to catch him.","“Yoshua, would you be willing to make a statement supporting Anthropic’s right to do business and pushing against unregulated killer robots?”. I clarified that his voice could influence the many gdm professionals who respect him, professionals who might be mobilized to push against “caving” to the Pentagon’s demands. He told me to email him.","Soon after, his office told me they decided they weren’t going to make a statement. They didn’t explain why not. Since I didn’t know Bengio, I figured I should focus my attention on Stuart Russell and then let him handle it.","At lunchtime, I saw Stuart speaking with someone 1-⁠on-⁠1. With the encouragement of several attendees, I overcame a dash of social anxiety and interrupted his conversation as politely as I could.","“Stuart, this is an extremely important situation and your voice matters,” I told him. “Can you make a statement? Can you get the iaseai organization to make a statement, too? Can you move the people inside of these companies?”. He considered. He agreed. He would try to get Bengio and Hinton on board. He would convene an iaseai vote asap and announce it at the closing of the conference later that day. He didn’t hedge his willingness to fight.","“Now that’s what I’m talking about,” I thought. “Here’s a powerful guy who knows his power.”","AI company / DoD deals mattered . They marked the first public, high-profile intersection between modern generative AI and military use restrictions. Whatever compromises (or capitulations) the companies made would reverberate as precedent into the future. Iaseai attendees had a chance to take their contributions from “abstract work which might inform policymakers” to “directly influencing precedent.” Stuart was now going to mobilize them.","As promised, he spoke about the issues at closing. I recorded his remarks during the Q&A, which were originally available on iaseai ’s conference schedule：https://www.iaseai.org/schedule-2026?date=2026-02-26 but were later migrated and not reuploaded to iaseai ’s official YouTube chan nel. ：https://www.youtube.com/@IASEAI","Should iaseai make a statement in support of Anthropic’s right not to have its software used in purposes that are outside the contracted areas that it agreed to have it used for?","The question said, “what about Google DeepMind, what about OpenAI”⁠—are they also going to take the same stand as Anthropic? It seems like that’s up to them, but the right of a company to say “we don’t want to sell our product for that purpose”⁠—and to be able to say that without threat of economic destruction. I’m not a lawyer, but it seems like that’s something that ought to be protected.","I was surprised. Stuart said “It seems like [taking the same stand] is up to them.” He didn’t encourage Google and OpenAI to avoid powering lethal autonomous weapons? Wasn’t that a defining cause for him over the last decade?","The next question from a conference attendee asked whether iaseai would take positions on current issues. As the session wrapped, iaseai ’s interim executive director Mark Nitzberg took the stage.","Many news outlets are discussing the extortion racket that the DoD is applying to Anthropic…","I think we will try to get an online poll if we have time to make this happen. So that we can publish a news release saying “92% (or whatever it turns out to be) of members of iaseai are in favour of the proposition that Anthropic should not be required to do what they don’t want to do.”","Stuart called the DoD’s actions an “extortion racket.” I appreciated the frankness, though frankness in the hall wasn’t the same as frankness in a statement the world would see. 5：#user-content-fn-coverage As I left, I signed up to be an iaseai member to participate in the poll. I thought it’d pass but wanted to make my voice heard. I paid the $75 membership fee.","Before the closing ceremony, Mark had texted me that the survey would close Thursday night. With 2/3 support, Stuart would sign a statement on iaseai ’s behalf, and without it, Stuart would sign a statement personally with the option for others to co-sign.","I left for an evening at the Louvre.","Thursday morning greeted me. I didn’t see how to vote in the poll. Strange. I texted Mark. He said iaseai would have to act after Anthropic’s Friday deadline.","I told Mark that the situation was urgent: Google and OpenAI could move at any point. I urged him to talk to Stuart about making his own statement, any statement. I appreciated that Mark was helping me figure out this situation. Later that day, Anthropic indicated they would stick to the red lines in their existing contract with DoD. ：https://www.anthropic.com/news/statement-department-of-war","(Thursday was supposed to be the start of a romantic vacation in Iceland. I didn’t really want to be doing any of this.)","Friday morning. Stuart had not made any public statement. I asked Mark, “What is possibly more important than spending a few minutes composing an email to his favorite reporter?”. From my conversation with Mark, I learned that neither Stuart nor iaseai would act.","But here’s the thing. Mark committed publ icly ：#stuart-closes-out-iaseai at closing that iaseai would hold a member poll. Mark encouraged people to pay dues and become members to participate. Then iaseai leadership silently cancelled the poll. 6：#user-content-fn-workshop No statement ever came.","Mark gave me an evolving list of reasons for his organization not making a statement:","I could appreciate the first reason: after all, Stuart had repeatedly disclaimed “time permitting” for making a statement before the deadline. But that last reason in particular didn’t make sense to me. Anthropic made a statement saying they won’t budge, so iaseai doesn’t need to make a statement supporting Anthropic?","The Pentagon set the Friday deadline for Anthropic, not for iaseai . The Anthropic autonomous weapons issue had been in the news for weeks：https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/pentagon-used-anthropics-claude-in-maduro-venezuela-raid-583aff17 prior. Anthropic’s lawsuit against the Pentagon：https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/891514/anthropic-pentagon-lawsuit-amicus-brief-openai-google ran for weeks after. Google wouldn’t sign for two more months. Iaseai had plenty of time to act and plenty of ways to act, like filing an amicus brief, putting out a statement, or contacting senior decision-makers at Google.","OpenAI did announce a deal on Fri day. ：https://openai.com/index/our-agreement-with-the-department-of-war/ OpenAI claimed its deal protected the same red lines against killer robots and mass surveillance that Anthropic had insisted upon. However, some analysts concluded that OpenAI’s contract language contains wide loopholes.：https://www.techpolicy.press/five-unresolved-issues-in-openais-deal-with-the-department-of-defense/"],"articleImages":[{"sourceUrl":"https://assets.turntrout.com/static/images/posts/Why%20I%20left%20Google%20DeepMind-06122026-1.avif?v=1","alt":"A smiling man with a beard and glasses, wearing light blue medical scrubs with \"VA MEDICAL CENTER\" visible on the chest, posing in front of an American flag.","afterParagraph":9,"url":"/media/articles/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/59fd5d0966d38748.avif"},{"sourceUrl":"https://assets.turntrout.com/static/images/posts/Why%20I%20left%20Google%20DeepMind-06102026.avif?v=1","alt":"Alex Turner stands in a garden at the UNESCO headquarters in Paris, wearing a conference badge. In the background, a large metal dome structure and numerous international flags are visible, with the Eiffel Tower rising in the distance.","afterParagraph":31,"url":"/media/articles/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/36ad8d3ae961a1bf.avif"},{"sourceUrl":"https://assets.turntrout.com/static/images/posts/Why%20I%20left%20Google%20DeepMind-06242026-8.avif?v=1","alt":"An auditorium filled with conference attendees, with the vast majority raising their hands in a show of support.","afterParagraph":45,"url":"/media/articles/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/dbe9d3d780089331.avif"}],"mediaStatus":"ok","articleBodyZh":["在一月份，国土安全部（DHS）官员至少杀害了两个人。在这两起案件中，一名联邦特工抓住他的枪，对一位和平的市民开枪并将其打死。","我了解到谷歌向国土安全部内的相关机构销售其云服务。我认为这是错误的。联邦特工不应该在街上杀害公民。我决定寻找最有效的方式推动我的公司停止为这些机构提供服务。我的撤资运动很快扩大成阻止谷歌签署不道德的军事人工智能协议的尝试，因为五角大楼开始施压人工智能供应商签署军事人工智能协议，而这些协议对杀人机器人或大规模监控的使用没有任何限制。","我希望人工智能伦理承诺在压力下仍能生效。特别是，我希望谷歌深度思维（GDM）保持其现有的反对支持杀人机器人的承诺。在几个月的时间里，我要求许多人采取行动。我请求高级人士——受人尊敬的人——那些因关注人工智能伦理和安全而声誉卓著的人。几乎所有人都拒绝了。","以Stuart Russell为例，这位著名的人工智能研究员花了十多年时间反对自主武器。我曾在他的实验室工作多年。在一次会议上，他在台上同意推动他的组织发表声明，支持人工智能供应商抵制政府胁迫，并承诺对组织成员进行投票。但声明和投票都消失了。","或者看看Jeff Dean，他是谷歌的首席科学家，也是谷歌双子AI项目的共同负责人。2018年，Jeff签署了一项承诺，永不支持发展或使用杀人机器人。我让Jeff公开并勇敢地共同签署了一份支持Anthropic对抗五角大楼的法庭之友简报（由外部人士介入以影响诉讼）。但我也要求他利用其巨大影响力阻止谷歌与军方签订不道德的协议，我认为他没有这样做。尽管有承诺，他仍在谷歌工作。","我写了一份25页的提案，其中包含合同条款和监督机制。军事和监控法律专家都称赞这份提案，这代表了一个原则性的还价，Google本可以支持它。我把提案发给了Demis Hassabis（gdm的CEO），他把它转给了高级政策人员，但提案最终无人理会，直到Google签署了协议。","高层管理坚持认为Google不会签署合同。我不同意他们的观点，但他们大多无视我的警告。虽然我可能增加了五角大楼在该交易上的犹豫，：#jeff-signs-an-amicus-brief-supporting-anthropic Google仍签署了一份协议，将他们的AI交出，而没有对杀人机器人或大规模AI监控设限。Google的合同限制甚至比OpenAI的还弱。：https://fortune.com/2026/05/04/google-employee-backlash-pentagon-ai-contract-power-waned-since-project-maven/ 那时，我已经无法在良知下继续留在Google，所以我选择离开。","这篇文章讲述了我为什么离开Google DeepMind的故事。这也是一个更大主题的故事：强大的个人和机构如何一次又一次在压力面前未能履行他们在AI伦理方面的承诺。","在整篇文章中，我从未在未经允许的情况下引用任何人的私人言论。在私人对话至关重要的情况下，我尽量进行了最简化的描述。除此之外，我保持只涉及自己的行动、公开信息和官方通信。你无法验证我的描述，因此请据此权衡。这种简化导致了我删减了一些本可支撑我论点的内容。","在Alex Pretti去世后，我决心采取有效行动。：https://turntrout.substack.com/p/a-winter-spent-by-the-pond 为了确定如何减少DHS带来的伤害，我研究了大型科技公司的纠葛。当然，微软和亚马逊的参与更大，：https://www.forbes.com/sites/the-wiretap/2026/01/27/immigration-record-spend-on-amazon-and-trump/ 但我惊讶地发现了Google的涉入情况。","典型的激进行动是发起请愿。但谷歌已经忽视了一份关于这个问题的大型请愿书。：https://www.cnbc.com/2026/02/07/nearly-a-thousand-google-workers-sign-letter-urging-company-to-divest-from-ice-cbp.html 而且，谷歌的高管很可能已经让公司对典型的组织策略产生了抵御。静坐、罢工，甚至大批谷歌工程师辞职：我认为这些都无效（即使我能实现它们）。","在我制定策略时，我判断谷歌不会在意100个随机研究工程师辞职。不，在AI行业，人才呈顶端集中，团队由少数难以替代的明星推动。我不需要协调100名工程师。也许我只需要协调10人。","我一直关注新闻，并猜测Sundar Pichai（谷歌CEO）更像是一个商人，而不是“写一篇关于道德的长篇演讲就能改变我想法”的那种人。但如果有几个难以替代的人准备离开，这对商业会有影响，所以Sundar可能会听取意见。","这时我想起读到Jeff Dean发推文批评ICE的糟糕行为，并转发Anne Frank的名言。也许我甚至不需要10名工程师，我只需要一个。","Jeff在谷歌被视为圣人。他是谷歌第30号员工，开发了关键算法，以原则性著称。一个常见的笑话是：在Jeff Dean的简历中，列出他没实现的事情比实现的事情更容易。他是谷歌的首席科学家，也是谷歌Gemini项目的联合负责人。Jeff的离开对公司将是灾难性的。","但如果Jeff如此关心并拥有如此影响力，为什么谷歌最初会参与这些ICE合同呢？当然，你不能只是通过威胁辞职就不断实现自己的愿望成为首席科学家。但我仍然感到困惑。","起初我考虑谁能把我和他联系起来。但（这是一个很好的通用经验）如果你想和某人讨论某事，你总是可以直接问他们！","我告诉Jeff，我尊重他发声，我希望谷歌退出DHS供应链。我问他是否也认同这些目标，如果是，我如何能帮忙。","他建议我给几个家伙发邮件是合理的。他们的名字是：Sundar Pichai（谷歌 CEO）、Demis Hassabis（Google DeepMind CEO）和 Thomas Kurian（谷歌云 CEO）。我当时想：“当然，Jeff。没问题。我就直接告诉他们我的想法。”","我以 gdm 的一名关注员工身份写信。我最近向 Jeff Dean 反映了我的担忧。他建议直接给你们三位发邮件是合理的下一步。","我对谷歌与美国任何一个政党合法政府合作没有问题。我的关注点不是政治，而是谷歌在 DHS 供应链中所起作用所促成的事件。","我认为 ICE 已经远远超出了其合法授权，超过了以有序方式驱逐非法移民出境的职责。据监督机构称，ICE 的行动经常剥夺对象的正当程序。这些行动经常拘留公民：https://www.cbsnews.com/minnesota/news/woman-american-citizen-describes-being-held-by-ice-for-two-days/，在设施中操作几乎没有（或没有）法律监督：https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/press-release/report-trump-immigration-detention-2026/。在其中一个地点，有超过 1000 人失踪：https://www.projectcensored.org/detainees-missing-ice-alligator-alcatraz/。在其他地点，ACLU 报告称存在侵犯人权行为，并且被拘留者的安全严重缺失：https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/detained-immigrants-detail-physical-abuse-and-inhumane-conditions-at-largest-immigration-detention-center-in-the-u-s","这些都不是标准的、合法的执法活动。从人权角度来看，这些行动令人担忧，同时也对任何参与的供应商构成声誉风险。","在2026年1月28日，国土安全部发布了其2025年人工智能使用案例清单：https://www.dhs.gov/publication/ai-use-case-inventory-library，该清单列出了谷歌作为多个生成式人工智能提供商之一，“提升国土安全部的运营效率”。我敦促谷歌立即停止与移民及海关执法局（及更广泛的国土安全部）的合作，包括通过支持促进这些特定操作的第三方整合商。无论是通过直接（“主合同”）合同还是通过中介（如 ITC Federal：https://itcfederal.com/news/itc-federal-achieves-ato-for-dhs-ice-cloud/），Cloud 和 Gemini 都不应支撑这些操作。","历史将通过科技行业在这些事件中的参与来评判我。我热爱在谷歌工作，我希望确保谷歌站在历史正确的一边。","他们没有回复。我回到杰夫那里，并请求安排一次午餐，讨论在谷歌内部实现真正变革的建设性机会。我告诉他：“任何时间，任何地点。我会开车去山景城和你见面。”","此时，我认为这是“计划A”会失败的地方。令我惊讶的是，他实际上接受了，约了几周后的午餐。","五角大楼希望前沿人工智能实验室 Anthropic 从其现有合同中移除红线：禁止致命自主武器系统和人工智能间谍/画像的红线。最后通牒本质上是“给我们你的产品，否则我们将把你列为供应链风险。”：https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/24/us/politics/pentagon-anthropic.html 政府希望人工智能用于“所有合法用途”。","这种交易存在两个主要问题。","我已经关注 Anthropic 与五角大楼的僵局好几周了。那天早上，我读到了关于最后通牒的消息。我正在巴黎参加国际安全与伦理人工智能协会（IASEAI）举办的会议，这是一个非营利组织：https://iaseai.org/about，成立于2024年，旨在成为安全与伦理人工智能的“统一声音”。世界著名人工智能科学家斯图尔特·拉塞尔（Stuart Russell）担任其指导委员会主席。其2026年的工作组：https://iaseai.org/working-groups 包括“高级人工智能红线”，专注于“自主武器和升级”。IASEAI似乎就是为这样一个时刻而建立的。","Iaseai 的会场将会聚集关心伦理的有影响力的 AI 专业人士。我想着：我们可以作为一个领域组织一次回应，以支持 1) Anthropic 在不受毁灭威胁的情况下开展业务的权利，以及 2) 关于是否以及如何将 AI 集成到致命自主武器系统和监控装置中的实际标准。","Anthropic 有两天时间来遵守政府的要求。也许其他公司会在截止日期前同意这些“所有合法用途”的条款。我心中盘旋的主要问题是：我能阻止谷歌屈服，接受“所有合法用途”的协议吗？如果 Anthropic 说“不”，谷歌也说“不”，那我们就有所进展了。这似乎很难。我仍然想让它发生。谷歌随时可能屈服，无论是在星期五截止日期之前还是之后。","当我到达 iaseai 会场时，我本以为数百名 AI 专业人士中的一些人会讨论刚刚发布的紧急 AI 伦理新闻。然而，除了我，没有人提起这件事。人们忙于处理平时的抽象问题：“公共选择理论如何影响协调问题？”","最重要的是：全球禁止致命自主武器运动的领导人物： https://awards.acm.org/award_winners/russell_3816360，他的网站上展示了 200 多场关于该主题的著名演讲：https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~russell/research/LAWS.html 他向联合国展示了 Slaughter bots：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-2tpwW0kmU 和视频：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rDo1QxI260。如果地球上有人有理由点出一个“所有合法用途”军事 AI 协议，那就是这个组织针对 slaughterbots 领域的人。","我迅速收集信息。Hinton 是远程发言，所以我必须间接联系他，可能通过 Bengio 或 Stuart。我已经认识 Stuart，并且有一个朋友可以帮我联系。Bengio 是个未知因素。我看到他正离开会场，于是我跑去追他。","“Yoshua，你愿意发表声明支持Anthropic的经营权，并反对不受监管的杀手机器人吗？”我澄清说，他的声音可以影响许多尊重他的gdm专业人士，而这些专业人士可能会被动员起来反对“向五角大楼的要求妥协”。他让我给他发电子邮件。","不久之后，他办公室告诉我，他们决定不发表声明。他们没有解释原因。由于我不认识Bengio，我认为我应该把注意力集中在Stuart Russell身上，然后让他来处理。","午餐时间，我看到Stuart正在与某人一对一交谈。在几位与会者的鼓励下，我克服了一点社交焦虑，尽量礼貌地打断了他的谈话。","“Stuart，这是一个极其重要的情况，你的声音很重要，”我告诉他。“你能发表声明吗？你能让iaseai组织也发表声明吗？你能调动这些公司内部的人吗？”他考虑了一下。他同意了。他会尝试让Bengio和Hinton支持。他会尽快召开iaseai投票，并在当天会议结束时宣布。他毫不犹豫地表示愿意参与斗争。","“这才是我所说的，”我心想。“这是一个知道自己力量的强大人物。”","AI公司/国防部的交易很重要。它们标志着现代生成式AI与军事使用限制之间首次公开、引人注目的交汇。无论公司做出什么妥协（或让步），都会作为先例在未来产生影响。iaseai的与会者有机会将他们的贡献从“可能影响政策制定者的抽象工作”提升为“直接影响先例”。Stuart现在将动员他们。","如承诺，他在闭幕时谈到了这些问题。我在问答环节录下了他的发言，这些发言最初可以在iaseai的会议日程上查看：https://www.iaseai.org/schedule-2026?date=2026-02-26，但后来被迁移并未重新上传到iaseai的官方YouTube频道：https://www.youtube.com/@IASEAI","iaseai是否应该发表声明，支持Anthropic的软件不被用于超出其合同约定用途之外的目的？","问题是，“那谷歌 DeepMind 呢，那 OpenAI 呢？”——他们也会采取和 Anthropic 一样的立场吗？这似乎由他们自己决定，但公司有权利说“我们不想为那个目的出售我们的产品”——而且可以在没有经济威胁的情况下说这句话。我不是律师，但这似乎是应该受到保护的权利。","我很惊讶。Stuart 说“似乎[采取相同立场]由他们决定。”他没有鼓励谷歌和 OpenAI 避免为致命自主武器提供动力吗？难道这不是他过去十年的一个明确主张吗？","会议与会者的下一个问题是问 iaseai 是否会对当前问题表态。会议结束时，iaseai 的临时执行董事 Mark Nitzberg 上台。","许多新闻媒体正在讨论国防部对 Anthropic 施加的勒索行为……","我认为如果有时间，我们会尝试做一个在线投票。这样我们就可以发布新闻稿，说“92%（或结果如何） 的 iaseai 成员支持这样一个提议：Anthropic 不应被要求去做他们不想做的事情。”","Stuart 称国防部的行为是“勒索行为”。我很欣赏他的直率，尽管在会场的直率与全世界会看到的声明中的直率不同。离开时，我注册成为 iaseai 成员以参与投票。我以为它会通过，但想让自己的声音被听见。我支付了 75 美元的会员费。","闭幕仪式前，Mark 发短信告诉我调查将在周四晚上结束。如果有 2/3 的支持，Stuart 会以 iaseai 的名义签署声明，如果不足，他将以个人身份签署声明，并允许他人共同签署。","我去了卢浮宫度过一个夜晚。","周四早晨到来。我没看到如何在投票中投票。很奇怪。我给 Mark 发了短信。他说 iaseai 将不得不在 Anthropic 周五的截止日期之后采取行动。","我告诉马克情况很紧急：谷歌和OpenAI随时可能采取行动。我督促他去和斯图尔特谈谈，发表他自己的声明，哪怕是任何声明。我很感激马克在帮我理清这个局面。当天晚些时候，Anthropic 表示他们会坚持与国防部现有合同中的红线。：https://www.anthropic.com/news/statement-department-of-war","（星期四本应该是冰岛浪漫假期的开始。我其实并不想做这些事情。）","星期五早上。斯图尔特还没有发表任何公开声明。我问马克：“还有什么事情比花几分钟给他最喜欢的记者写封邮件更重要吗？”从我和马克的对话中，我了解到斯图尔特和 iaseai 都不会采取行动。","但问题是这样的。马克在收尾时公开承诺：#stuart-closes-out-iaseai iaseai 会进行会员投票。马克鼓励人们缴纳会员费并成为会员以参与投票。然后 iaseai 领导层默默取消了投票。 #user-content-fn-workshop 从未发表任何声明。","马克给了我一个不断变化的关于他所在组织不发表声明的理由清单：","我能理解第一个理由：毕竟，斯图尔特一再表示“如果有时间的话”才会在截止日期前发表声明。但最后一个理由特别让我不理解。Anthropic 已经发表声明表示他们不会让步，所以 iaseai 不需要发表支持 Anthropic 的声明吗？","五角大楼设定的是 Anthropic 的星期五截止日期，而不是 iaseai。有关 Anthropic 自主武器的问题已经在新闻中出现数周：https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/pentagon-used-anthropics-claude-in-maduro-venezuela-raid-583aff17 之前。Anthropic 对五角大楼的诉讼：https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/891514/anthropic-pentagon-lawsuit-amicus-brief-openai-google 在数周后继续进行。谷歌要两个月后才签署。Iaseai 有足够的时间采取行动，也有很多方式可以采取行动，比如提交法律之友意见书、发布声明或者联系谷歌的高级决策者。","OpenAI确实在周五宣布了一项协议。：https://openai.com/index/our-agreement-with-the-department-of-war/ OpenAI声称其协议保护了与Anthropic坚持的同样的对杀手机器人和大规模监控的红线。然而，一些分析人士认为OpenAI的合同条款存在较大的漏洞。：https://www.techpolicy.press/five-unresolved-issues-in-openais-deal-with-the-department-of-defense/"],"translationStatus":"translated","bodyOrigin":"source-page","editorial":{"summary":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner自述，因不认同谷歌向美国国土安全部相关机构提供云服务，并认为公司签署的军事AI协议缺少对杀手机器人和大规模监控用途的限制，最终选择离职。","background":"Turner称，他曾起草一份25页提案，纳入合同限制条款与监督机制，并提交给DeepMind首席执行官Demis Hassabis。提案被转交高级政策人员后未获进一步跟进，谷歌随后签署相关协议。","viewpoint":"Aioga判断，这篇文章的核心并非单纯记录一次离职，而是质疑AI伦理承诺能否在政府压力和商业决策面前持续有效。文中关于组织失职及个人未兑现承诺的评价，主要来自Turner本人陈述。","implications":"值得关注的是，军事AI合同是否明确排除自主武器与大规模监控用途，可能成为检验企业伦理承诺的重要标准。文章也显示，公开签署原则性承诺与实际推动合同约束之间可能存在落差。","nextStep":"后续应关注谷歌是否公开相关军事AI合同的用途限制、监督机制和执行规则，以及文中被点名的机构或人士是否回应。对Turner关于内部沟通、提案处理和协议限制的说法，也需要更多独立材料核实。","evidenceRefs":["title","summary","articleBody","source"],"status":"published","aiGenerated":true,"autoApproved":true,"generatedBy":"aioga-editorial:gpt-5.6-sol","reviewedBy":"aioga-editorial-review:gpt-5.6-sol","generatedAt":"2026-07-22T22:50:42.927Z","sourceHash":"3e7458a2ae04e647","review":{"approved":true,"groundedness":96,"clarity":93,"duplicationRisk":18,"blockingIssues":[],"notes":["候选内容对离职原因、25页提案的流转及谷歌最终签署协议等信息均采用了“自述”“Turner称”“认为”等归因表述，避免将单方说法写成已独立证实的事实。","viewpoint与implications明确属于编辑判断或延伸观察，没有冒充来源中的客观事实。","nextStep已提示Turner对内部沟通、提案处理及协议限制的说法仍需独立材料核实，风险说明充分。"]},"validation":{"passed":true,"mode":"ai-auto","revisions":0,"checks":["schema","length","source-attribution","low-source-overlap","no-html","independent-ai-review"]}},"tags":["技巧观点","Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）"],"translations":{"zh-CN":{"title":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员因公司签署无限制军事AI协议而离职","summary":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner因谷歌向国土安全部出售云服务并最终签署无限制军事AI协议而离职。他曾起草25页提案要求加入禁止杀手机器人和大规模监控的合同条款，但提案被CEO转交后无人跟进。Turner指出，包括Jeff Dean和Stuart Russell在内的多位AI伦理领袖在关键时刻未能兑现承诺。","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员因公司签署无限制军事AI协议而离职 - Aioga AI资讯","description":"前谷歌DeepMind研究员Alex Turner因谷歌向国土安全部出售云服务并最终签署无限制军事AI协议而离职。他曾起草25页提案要求加入禁止杀手机器人和大规模监控的合同条款，但提案被CEO转交后无人跟进。Turner指出，包括Jeff Dean和Stuart Russell在内的多位AI伦理领袖在关键时刻未能兑现承诺。","url":"https://www.aioga.com/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/"},"en":{"title":"A former Google DeepMind researcher left after the company signed an unlimited military AI agreement","summary":"Former Google DeepMind researcher Alex Turner left after Google sold cloud services to the Department of Homeland Security and eventually signed an unlimited military AI agreement. He once drafted a 25-page proposal calling for contract clauses banning killer robots and mass surveillance, but after the proposal was forwarded by the CEO, no one followed up. Turner pointed out that several AI ethics leaders, including Jeff Dean and Stuart Russell, failed to deliver on their promises at critical moments.","category":"Insights","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"A former Google DeepMind researcher left after the company signed an unlimited military AI agreement - Aioga AI News","description":"Former Google DeepMind researcher Alex Turner left after Google sold cloud services to the Department of Homeland Security and eventually signed an unlimited military AI agreement.","url":"https://www.aioga.com/en/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:04.372Z"},"ja":{"title":"元Google DeepMindのリサーチャーが、同社が無制限の軍事AI契約を締結した後に退職しました","summary":"元Google DeepMindのリサーチャー、アレックス・ターナーは、Googleがクラウドサービスを国土安全保障省に売却し、最終的に無制限の軍事AI契約に署名した後に退職しました。 かつて彼は殺人ロボットと大量監視を禁止する契約条項を求める25ページの提案書を起草したが、CEOが提案を提出した後、誰も追いかけなかった。 ターナーは、ジェフ・ディーンやスチュアート・ラッセルを含む複数のAI倫理リーダーが重要な場面で約束を果たせなかったことを指摘しました。","category":"ヒントと視点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"元Google DeepMindのリサーチャーが、同社が無制限の軍事AI契約を締結した後に退職しました - Aioga AIニュース","description":"元Google DeepMindのリサーチャー、アレックス・ターナーは、Googleがクラウドサービスを国土安全保障省に売却し、最終的に無制限の軍事AI契約に署名した後に退職しました。 かつて彼は殺人ロボットと大量監視を禁止する契約条項を求める25ページの提案書を起草したが、CEOが提案を提出した後、誰も追いかけなかった。 ターナーは、ジェフ・ディーンやスチ","url":"https://www.aioga.com/ja/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:04.580Z"},"ko":{"title":"구글 딥마인드의 전 연구원이 무제한 군사 AI 계약을 체결한 후 떠났습니다","summary":"구글 딥마인드 연구원 알렉스 터너는 구글이 클라우드 서비스를 국토안보부에 매각하고 결국 무제한 군사 AI 계약을 체결한 후 떠났습니다. 그는 한때 킬러 로봇과 대규모 감시를 금지하는 계약 조항을 요구하는 25페이지 분량의 제안서를 작성했지만, CEO가 제안을 전달한 후 아무도 후속 조치를 취하지 않았습니다. 터너는 제프 딘과 스튜어트 러셀을 포함한 여러 AI 윤리 리더들이 중요한 순간에 약속을 지키지 못했다고 지적했다.","category":"인사이트","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"구글 딥마인드의 전 연구원이 무제한 군사 AI 계약을 체결한 후 떠났습니다 - Aioga AI 뉴스","description":"구글 딥마인드 연구원 알렉스 터너는 구글이 클라우드 서비스를 국토안보부에 매각하고 결국 무제한 군사 AI 계약을 체결한 후 떠났습니다. 그는 한때 킬러 로봇과 대규모 감시를 금지하는 계약 조항을 요구하는 25페이지 분량의 제안서를 작성했지만, CEO가 제안을 전달한 후 아무도 후속 조치를 취하지 않았습니다. 터너는 제프 ","url":"https://www.aioga.com/ko/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:04.538Z"},"es":{"title":"Un antiguo investigador de Google DeepMind se marchó después de que la empresa firmara un acuerdo ilimitado de IA militar","summary":"El exinvestigador de Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, se marchó después de que Google vendiera servicios en la nube al Departamento de Seguridad Nacional y finalmente firmara un acuerdo ilimitado de IA militar. En una ocasión redactó una propuesta de 25 páginas que pedía cláusulas contractuales que prohibieran robots asesinos y la vigilancia masiva, pero tras la propuesta remitida por el CEO, nadie siguió adelante. Turner señaló que varios líderes de ética en IA, incluidos Jeff Dean y Stuart Russell, no cumplieron sus promesas en momentos críticos.","category":"Ideas","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Un antiguo investigador de Google DeepMind se marchó después de que la empresa firmara un acuerdo ilimitado de IA militar - Aioga Noticias de IA","description":"El exinvestigador de Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, se marchó después de que Google vendiera servicios en la nube al Departamento de Seguridad Nacional y finalmente firmara un acuer","url":"https://www.aioga.com/es/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:04.677Z"},"fr":{"title":"Un ancien chercheur chez Google DeepMind est parti après que l’entreprise a signé un accord illimité sur l’IA militaire","summary":"L’ancien chercheur de Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, est parti après que Google a vendu des services cloud au Département de la Sécurité intérieure et a finalement signé un accord illimité sur l’IA militaire. Il a un jour rédigé une proposition de 25 pages appelant à des clauses contractuelles interdisant les robots tueurs et la surveillance de masse, mais après que la proposition ait été transmise par le PDG, personne n’a donné suite. Turner a souligné que plusieurs leaders de l’éthique de l’IA, dont Jeff Dean et Stuart Russell, n’ont pas tenu leurs promesses à des moments critiques.","category":"Analyses","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Un ancien chercheur chez Google DeepMind est parti après que l’entreprise a signé un accord illimité sur l’IA militaire - Aioga Actualités IA","description":"L’ancien chercheur de Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, est parti après que Google a vendu des services cloud au Département de la Sécurité intérieure et a finalement signé un accord i","url":"https://www.aioga.com/fr/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:04.599Z"},"de":{"title":"Ein ehemaliger Google-DeepMind-Forscher verließ die Firma, nachdem das Unternehmen eine unbegrenzte militärische KI-Vereinbarung unterschrieben hatte","summary":"Der ehemalige Google DeepMind-Forscher Alex Turner verließ die Organisation, nachdem Google Cloud-Dienste an das Department of Homeland Security verkauft hatte und schließlich eine Vereinbarung zur unbegrenzten militärischen KI unterzeichnete. Er entwarf einmal einen 25-seitigen Vorschlag, der Vertragsklauseln zum Verbot von Killerrobotern und Massenüberwachung forderte, doch nachdem der Vorschlag vom CEO vorgelegt wurde, folgte niemand weiter. Turner wies darauf hin, dass mehrere KI-Ethik-Führungskräfte, darunter Jeff Dean und Stuart Russell, ihre Versprechen in entscheidenden Momenten nicht eingelöst haben.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Ein ehemaliger Google-DeepMind-Forscher verließ die Firma, nachdem das Unternehmen eine unbegrenzte militärische KI-Vereinbarung unterschrieben hatte - Aioga KI-News","description":"Der ehemalige Google DeepMind-Forscher Alex Turner verließ die Organisation, nachdem Google Cloud-Dienste an das Department of Homeland Security verkauft hatte und schließlich eine","url":"https://www.aioga.com/de/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:10.277Z"},"pt-BR":{"title":"Um ex-pesquisador do Google DeepMind saiu após a empresa assinar um acordo ilimitado de IA militar","summary":"O ex-pesquisador do Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, saiu depois que o Google vendeu serviços em nuvem para o Departamento de Segurança Interna e acabou assinando um acordo ilimitado de IA militar. Ele chegou a redigir uma proposta de 25 páginas pedindo cláusulas contratuais proibindo robôs assassinos e vigilância em massa, mas após a proposta ser encaminhada pelo CEO, ninguém deu seguimento. Turner apontou que vários líderes éticos da IA, incluindo Jeff Dean e Stuart Russell, não cumpriram suas promessas em momentos críticos.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Um ex-pesquisador do Google DeepMind saiu após a empresa assinar um acordo ilimitado de IA militar - Aioga Notícias de IA","description":"O ex-pesquisador do Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, saiu depois que o Google vendeu serviços em nuvem para o Departamento de Segurança Interna e acabou assinando um acordo ilimitado ","url":"https://www.aioga.com/pt-BR/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:07.000Z"},"ru":{"title":"Бывший исследователь Google DeepMind ушёл после того, как компания подписала соглашение о неограниченном военном ИИ","summary":"Бывший исследователь Google DeepMind Алекс Тернер ушёл после того, как Google продал облачные сервисы Министерству внутренней безопасности и в итоге подписал соглашение о неограниченном военном ИИ. Однажды он подготовил 25-страничное предложение с предложением о запрете убийственных роботов и массового наблюдения, но после того, как предложение было передано генеральным директором, никто не стал продолжать. Тернер отметил, что несколько лидеров этики ИИ, включая Джеффа Дина и Стюарта Рассела, не выполнили свои обещания в критические моменты.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Бывший исследователь Google DeepMind ушёл после того, как компания подписала соглашение о неограниченном военном ИИ - Aioga Новости ИИ","description":"Бывший исследователь Google DeepMind Алекс Тернер ушёл после того, как Google продал облачные сервисы Министерству внутренней безопасности и в итоге подписал соглашение о неогранич","url":"https://www.aioga.com/ru/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:07.272Z"},"ar":{"title":"غادر باحث سابق في Google DeepMind بعد توقيع الشركة اتفاقية ذكاء اصطناعي عسكري غير محدود","summary":"غادر أليكس تورنر، الباحث السابق في جوجل ديب مايند، بعد أن باعت جوجل خدمات السحابة لوزارة الأمن الداخلي ووقعت في النهاية اتفاقية ذكاء اصطناعي عسكري غير محدود. وقد صاغ ذات مرة اقتراحا من 25 صفحة يدعو إلى بنود تعاقدية تحظر الروبوتات القاتلة والمراقبة الجماعية، لكن بعد أن تم تمرير الاقتراح من قبل الرئيس التنفيذي، لم يتابع أحد العرض. أشار تيرنر إلى أن عدة قادة أخلاقيات في الذكاء الاصطناعي، بمن فيهم جيف دين وستيوارت راسل، فشلوا في الوفاء بوعودهم في اللحظات الحرجة.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"غادر باحث سابق في Google DeepMind بعد توقيع الشركة اتفاقية ذكاء اصطناعي عسكري غير محدود - Aioga أخبار الذكاء الاصطناعي","description":"غادر أليكس تورنر، الباحث السابق في جوجل ديب مايند، بعد أن باعت جوجل خدمات السحابة لوزارة الأمن الداخلي ووقعت في النهاية اتفاقية ذكاء اصطناعي عسكري غير محدود. وقد صاغ ذات مرة اقتراح","url":"https://www.aioga.com/ar/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:10.127Z"},"hi":{"title":"Google के एक पूर्व डीपमाइंड शोधकर्ता ने कंपनी द्वारा असीमित सैन्य AI समझौते पर हस्ताक्षर करने के बाद छोड़ दिया","summary":"Google के पूर्व डीपमाइंड शोधकर्ता एलेक्स टर्नर ने Google द्वारा होमलैंड सिक्योरिटी विभाग को क्लाउड सेवाएं बेचने और अंततः एक असीमित सैन्य AI समझौते पर हस्ताक्षर करने के बाद छोड़ दिया। उन्होंने एक बार 25 पन्नों के प्रस्ताव का मसौदा तैयार किया था, जिसमें हत्यारे रोबोट और बड़े पैमाने पर निगरानी पर प्रतिबंध लगाने वाले अनुबंध खंडों का आह्वान किया गया था, लेकिन सीईओ द्वारा प्रस्ताव को अग्रेषित किए जाने के बाद, किसी ने भी इसका पालन नहीं किया। टर्नर ने बताया कि जेफ डीन और स्टुअर्ट रसेल सहित कई एआई नैतिकता नेता महत्वपूर्ण क्षणों में अपने वादों को पूरा करने में विफल रहे।","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Google के एक पूर्व डीपमाइंड शोधकर्ता ने कंपनी द्वारा असीमित सैन्य AI समझौते पर हस्ताक्षर करने के बाद छोड़ दिया - Aioga AI समाचार","description":"Google के पूर्व डीपमाइंड शोधकर्ता एलेक्स टर्नर ने Google द्वारा होमलैंड सिक्योरिटी विभाग को क्लाउड सेवाएं बेचने और अंततः एक असीमित सैन्य AI समझौते पर हस्ताक्षर करने के बाद छोड़ दिय","url":"https://www.aioga.com/hi/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:07.895Z"},"it":{"title":"Un ex ricercatore di Google DeepMind ha lasciato dopo che l'azienda ha firmato un accordo illimitato sull'IA militare","summary":"L'ex ricercatore di Google DeepMind Alex Turner ha lasciato dopo che Google ha venduto servizi cloud al Dipartimento della Sicurezza Interna e ha infine firmato un accordo illimitato sull'IA militare. Una volta ha redatto una proposta di 25 pagine che chiedeva clausole contrattuali che vietano robot assassini e sorveglianza di massa, ma dopo che la proposta è stata inoltrata dal CEO, nessuno ha fatto seguito. Turner ha sottolineato che diversi leader dell'etica dell'IA, tra cui Jeff Dean e Stuart Russell, non hanno mantenuto le promesse nei momenti critici.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Un ex ricercatore di Google DeepMind ha lasciato dopo che l'azienda ha firmato un accordo illimitato sull'IA militare - Aioga Notizie IA","description":"L'ex ricercatore di Google DeepMind Alex Turner ha lasciato dopo che Google ha venduto servizi cloud al Dipartimento della Sicurezza Interna e ha infine firmato un accordo illimita","url":"https://www.aioga.com/it/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:10.790Z"},"nl":{"title":"Een voormalig Google DeepMind-onderzoeker vertrok nadat het bedrijf een onbeperkte militaire AI-overeenkomst had ondertekend","summary":"Voormalig Google DeepMind-onderzoeker Alex Turner vertrok nadat Google clouddiensten verkocht aan het Department of Homeland Security en uiteindelijk een onbeperkte militaire AI-overeenkomst tekende. Hij stelde ooit een voorstel van 25 pagina's op waarin hij opriep tot contractclausules die moordrobots en massale surveillance verboden, maar nadat het voorstel door de CEO was ingediend, volgde niemand dit op. Turner wees erop dat verschillende AI-ethiekleiders, waaronder Jeff Dean en Stuart Russell, hun beloften op cruciale momenten niet hebben nagekomen.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Een voormalig Google DeepMind-onderzoeker vertrok nadat het bedrijf een onbeperkte militaire AI-overeenkomst had ondertekend - Aioga AI-nieuws","description":"Voormalig Google DeepMind-onderzoeker Alex Turner vertrok nadat Google clouddiensten verkocht aan het Department of Homeland Security en uiteindelijk een onbeperkte militaire AI-ov","url":"https://www.aioga.com/nl/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:07.398Z"},"tr":{"title":"Eski bir Google DeepMind araştırmacısı, şirketin sınırsız askeri yapay zeka anlaşması imzalamasının ardından ayrıldı","summary":"Eski Google DeepMind araştırmacısı Alex Turner, Google'ın bulut hizmetlerini İç Güvenlik Bakanlığı'na satması ve sonunda sınırsız askeri bir yapay zeka anlaşması imzalamasının ardından ayrıldı. Bir keresinde katil robotları ve kitlesel gözetimi yasaklayan sözleşme maddeleri içeren 25 sayfalık bir öneri taslağı hazırlamıştı, ancak CEO tarafından iletilmesinden sonra kimse takip etmedi. Turner, Jeff Dean ve Stuart Russell dahil olmak üzere birkaç yapay zeka etik liderinin kritik anlarda verdikleri sözleri yerine getirmediğini belirtti.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Eski bir Google DeepMind araştırmacısı, şirketin sınırsız askeri yapay zeka anlaşması imzalamasının ardından ayrıldı - Aioga AI Haberleri","description":"Eski Google DeepMind araştırmacısı Alex Turner, Google'ın bulut hizmetlerini İç Güvenlik Bakanlığı'na satması ve sonunda sınırsız askeri bir yapay zeka anlaşması imzalamasının ardı","url":"https://www.aioga.com/tr/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:11.205Z"},"vi":{"title":"Một cựu nhà nghiên cứu của Google DeepMind đã rời đi sau khi công ty ký thỏa thuận AI quân sự không giới hạn","summary":"Cựu nhà nghiên cứu Google DeepMind Alex Turner đã rời đi sau khi Google bán các dịch vụ đám mây cho Bộ An ninh Nội địa và cuối cùng đã ký một thỏa thuận AI quân sự không giới hạn. Ông đã từng soạn thảo một đề xuất dài 25 trang kêu gọi các điều khoản hợp đồng cấm robot sát thủ và giám sát hàng loạt, nhưng sau khi đề xuất được CEO chuyển tiếp, không ai theo dõi. Turner chỉ ra rằng một số nhà lãnh đạo đạo đức AI, bao gồm Jeff Dean và Stuart Russell, đã không thực hiện lời hứa của họ vào những thời điểm quan trọng.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Một cựu nhà nghiên cứu của Google DeepMind đã rời đi sau khi công ty ký thỏa thuận AI quân sự không giới hạn - Tin tức AI Aioga","description":"Cựu nhà nghiên cứu Google DeepMind Alex Turner đã rời đi sau khi Google bán các dịch vụ đám mây cho Bộ An ninh Nội địa và cuối cùng đã ký một thỏa thuận AI quân sự không giới hạn. ","url":"https://www.aioga.com/vi/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:07.768Z"},"id":{"title":"Seorang mantan peneliti Google DeepMind pergi setelah perusahaan menandatangani perjanjian AI militer tak terbatas","summary":"Mantan peneliti Google DeepMind Alex Turner pergi setelah Google menjual layanan cloud ke Departemen Keamanan Dalam Negeri dan akhirnya menandatangani perjanjian AI militer tak terbatas. Dia pernah menyusun proposal setebal 25 halaman yang menyerukan klausul kontrak yang melarang robot pembunuh dan pengawasan massal, tetapi setelah proposal itu diteruskan oleh CEO, tidak ada yang menindaklanjuti. Turner menunjukkan bahwa beberapa pemimpin etika AI, termasuk Jeff Dean dan Stuart Russell, gagal memenuhi janji mereka pada saat-saat kritis.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Seorang mantan peneliti Google DeepMind pergi setelah perusahaan menandatangani perjanjian AI militer tak terbatas - Berita AI Aioga","description":"Mantan peneliti Google DeepMind Alex Turner pergi setelah Google menjual layanan cloud ke Departemen Keamanan Dalam Negeri dan akhirnya menandatangani perjanjian AI militer tak ter","url":"https://www.aioga.com/id/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:11.252Z"},"th":{"title":"อดีตนักวิจัย Google DeepMind ลาออกหลังจากที่บริษัทลงนามในข้อตกลง AI ทางทหารแบบไม่จํากัด","summary":"Alex Turner อดีตนักวิจัยของ Google DeepMind ลาออกหลังจากที่ Google ขายบริการคลาวด์ให้กับกระทรวงความมั่นคงแห่งมาตุภูมิ และในที่สุดก็ลงนามในข้อตกลง AI ทางทหารแบบไม่จํากัด เขาเคยร่างข้อเสนอ 25 หน้าเพื่อเรียกร้องให้มีข้อสัญญาห้ามหุ่นยนต์นักฆ่าและการเฝ้าระวังจํานวนมาก แต่หลังจากที่ซีอีโอส่งต่อข้อเสนอแล้ว ก็ไม่มีใครติดตาม เทอร์เนอร์ชี้ให้เห็นว่าผู้นําด้านจริยธรรม AI หลายคน รวมถึง Jeff Dean และ Stuart Russell ล้มเหลวในการทําตามสัญญาในช่วงเวลาวิกฤต","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"อดีตนักวิจัย Google DeepMind ลาออกหลังจากที่บริษัทลงนามในข้อตกลง AI ทางทหารแบบไม่จํากัด - ข่าว AI Aioga","description":"Alex Turner อดีตนักวิจัยของ Google DeepMind ลาออกหลังจากที่ Google ขายบริการคลาวด์ให้กับกระทรวงความมั่นคงแห่งมาตุภูมิ และในที่สุดก็ลงนามในข้อตกลง AI ทางทหารแบบไม่จํากัด เขาเคยร่างข","url":"https://www.aioga.com/th/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:08.303Z"},"pl":{"title":"Były badacz Google DeepMind odszedł po podpisaniu przez firmę umowy o nieograniczonej wojskowej sztucznej inteligencji","summary":"Były badacz Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, odszedł po tym, jak Google sprzedało usługi chmurowe Departamentowi Bezpieczeństwa Wewnętrznego i ostatecznie podpisało umowę o nieograniczonej wojskowej sztucznej inteligencji. Kiedyś sporządził 25-stronicową propozycję zawierającą klauzule kontraktowe zakazujące robotów zabójców i masowego nadzoru, ale po przekazaniu tej propozycji przez CEO nikt już nie podjął dalszych działań. Turner zwrócił uwagę, że kilku liderów etyki AI, w tym Jeff Dean i Stuart Russell, nie dotrzymało swoich obietnic w kluczowych momentach.","category":"技巧观点","source":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","aggregationSource":"Hacker News 热门（buzzing.cc 中文翻译）","pageTitle":"Były badacz Google DeepMind odszedł po podpisaniu przez firmę umowy o nieograniczonej wojskowej sztucznej inteligencji - Aioga Wiadomości AI","description":"Były badacz Google DeepMind, Alex Turner, odszedł po tym, jak Google sprzedało usługi chmurowe Departamentowi Bezpieczeństwa Wewnętrznego i ostatecznie podpisało umowę o nieogranic","url":"https://www.aioga.com/pl/news/cmrmibbm801m8biulhl6uejzo/","contentTranslated":true,"sourceHash":"b183cb09901548f4","translatedAt":"2026-07-19T13:34:11.122Z"}}}}